Peer Review Process

Peer Review Process

Ceddi Journal of Law and Reality (CJLR) applies a double-blind peer-review process. All original research articles published by the journal undergo evaluation by at least two independent external reviewers before acceptance. Editorial screening determines whether a submission proceeds to external review.

Initial Editorial Screening

All submissions are screened for relevance to the journal’s Focus and Scope, originality, contribution to legal scholarship, methodological or analytical rigour, ethical compliance, and adherence to the Author Guidelines. Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be returned for correction or rejected before external peer review.

Initial screening includes similarity checks using Turnitin or iThenticate. Reports are assessed in context, including properly attributed quotations from legislation, judgments, and other legal authorities. A similarity percentage alone does not establish plagiarism or determine an editorial decision. Suspected misconduct is addressed under the journal’s Publication Ethics and Plagiarism Policy.

Suitable submissions are assigned to a handling editor with relevant expertise and no conflict of interest. The editor selects reviewers according to their subject knowledge, relevant methodological or legal expertise, independence, and ability to provide an impartial assessment. Reviewers must not be members of the journal’s editorial team or editorial board.

Double-Blind Peer Review

Author and reviewer identities are concealed from each other during peer review. Authors must submit a separate title page and an anonymised manuscript, removing identifying information from the text, comments, tracked changes, and document properties. Identifying declarations and acknowledgements must be supplied separately and restored in the accepted manuscript. Previous work should be cited neutrally rather than omitted when necessary for the analysis.

Editors check anonymisation before sending manuscripts for review. Complete anonymity cannot always be assured, particularly when related work is publicly available. Reviewers who recognise or reasonably suspect an author’s identity must inform the handling editor, who will assess whether an impartial review remains possible and arrange a replacement reviewer where necessary.

Reviewers provide objective, constructive, respectful, and evidence-based evaluations. They should explain substantive concerns, distinguish essential revisions from optional suggestions, and identify relevant limitations. Requests for additional citations must be justified by scholarly relevance and must not be made solely to increase citations to a reviewer, editor, journal, or institution.

Confidentiality and Conflicts of Interest

Submitted manuscripts, review reports, and editorial correspondence are confidential and are accessible only to authorised participants in the editorial process. Review reports are not published with articles, and reviewer identities are not publicly linked to individual manuscripts. Editors and reviewers must not use unpublished information or ideas obtained through the review process for personal or professional advantage.

Reviewers must not share manuscripts or involve another person in a review without prior editorial authorisation. Editors and reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts, review reports, or other confidential review materials to generative AI services. Reviewers remain personally responsible for the substance and accuracy of their assessments.

Editors and reviewers must disclose actual or potential competing interests before accepting an assignment and whenever a conflict becomes apparent. Relevant circumstances may include current institutional relationships, recent collaboration, supervisory relationships, financial interests, personal relationships, direct academic competition, litigation involvement, consultancy, or advocacy related to the manuscript. Individuals with a conflict that compromises impartiality must not participate in the manuscript’s evaluation or decision-making.

Reviewers who identify suspected plagiarism, fabricated authorities or data, undisclosed competing interests, or other ethical concerns must report them confidentially to the handling editor. They should not contact the authors directly or conduct an independent investigation. The editorial office assesses such concerns under the journal’s published ethics procedures.

Review Criteria

Reviewers assess manuscripts according to the research approach used, with particular attention to:

  • Relevance to the journal’s focus on the interpretation, application, implementation, enforcement, or consequences of law.
  • Originality, a clearly defined legal problem or research questions, and a distinct contribution to legal scholarship.
  • Appropriate selection, accuracy, legal status, and interpretation of legal authorities, scholarly literature, and supporting evidence.
  • Methodological transparency and analytical rigour appropriate to doctrinal, normative, statutory, case-law, comparative, empirical socio-legal, or combined approaches.
  • Coherence of legal reasoning, engagement with competing interpretations, and adequate support for findings and conclusions.
  • Implications for law, legal practice, institutions, rights, justice, governance, or public policy, together with recognition of limitations.
  • Ethical compliance, including appropriate safeguards for human participants, personal data, and confidential or privileged materials where applicable.
  • Clarity of presentation, accurate citations and references, and compliance with the Author Guidelines and manuscript template.

Doctrinal and normative studies are not required to include empirical data. They must develop an original, critical, and reasoned legal argument and explain its implications for law or legal practice. Claims about actual implementation, effectiveness, causation, or social outcomes must be supported by evidence appropriate to those claims. Descriptive summaries of legal provisions without substantial legal analysis do not meet the journal’s requirements.

Editorial Independence

Manuscripts submitted by editorial team or editorial board members are subject to the same screening, scholarly standards, and external review requirements as other submissions. An editor without a conflict of interest manages the submission and obtains assessments from at least two independent external reviewers.

An authoring editor or board member must not select reviewers or participate in editorial deliberations or decisions concerning their manuscript. The editorial office must restrict their access to confidential reviewer identities and internal records for that submission. If the Editor-in-Chief is an author or otherwise has a conflict of interest, an appropriate editor without that conflict assumes responsibility for the evaluation and final decision.

Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, relevance, and ethical compliance. The publisher and funding bodies must not interfere with individual acceptance decisions. Publication fees, waiver arrangements, and authors’ ability to pay must not influence reviewer recommendations or editorial decisions.

Editorial Decisions and Revisions

Following peer review and editorial assessment, a manuscript may receive one of the following decisions:

  • Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal’s requirements or has substantial concerns that cannot be adequately resolved through revision.
  • Major Revision: Substantial changes to the analysis, methodology, argument, supporting evidence, or presentation are required before further consideration.
  • Minor Revision: Limited changes or clarifications are required before a final decision.
  • Accept: The manuscript meets the journal’s scholarly and ethical requirements and may proceed to production.

Authors receive the editorial decision and relevant reviewer and editorial comments. Authors invited to revise must submit an anonymised revised manuscript and a point-by-point response explaining how each substantive comment has been addressed. Where authors disagree with a recommendation, they should provide a reasoned explanation supported by appropriate evidence or legal argument.

Revision deadlines are communicated in the decision letter. Authors who need additional time should contact the handling editor. Depending on the nature and extent of the changes, revised manuscripts may be assessed by the editor or returned to the original or additional independent external reviewers. An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.

The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision based on reviewers’ reports, the handling editor’s assessment, authors’ responses, and compliance with journal policies. If the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, this responsibility is delegated to an appropriate editor without that conflict. Reviewer recommendations inform the decision; they do not constitute a vote. Conflicting reports may be resolved through editorial assessment or an additional independent external review.

Editorial and Publishing Process

  1. Submission: Authors submit a separate title page, an anonymised manuscript, and required supporting information through the CJLR online submission system.
  2. Initial Editorial Screening: Editors assess scope, originality, scholarly quality, submission requirements, ethical compliance, anonymisation, and similarity reports. Submissions may be returned for correction or rejected at this stage.
  3. Editor Assignment: A handling editor with relevant expertise and no conflict of interest manages the evaluation.
  4. External Peer Review: At least two independent external reviewers evaluate each manuscript proceeding to double-blind peer review.
  5. Editorial Decision: Authors receive a decision together with relevant reviewer and editorial comments.
  6. Revision and Further Review, Where Required: Authors revise the manuscript and provide a point-by-point response. The editor assesses the revision and arranges further external review where necessary.
  7. Final Decision: The Editor-in-Chief, or a delegated editor without a conflict of interest, determines acceptance or rejection.
  8. Copyediting and Typesetting: Accepted manuscripts undergo language and presentation checks, formatting, and preparation for publication.
  9. Proofing: Authors check proofs for accuracy before publication. Substantive changes require editorial approval and may require further assessment.
  10. Online Publication: Articles are freely accessible immediately upon publication without subscription or embargo under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license. Authors retain copyright and grant the journal the right of first publication.

Review Timeline and Withdrawal

Processing times vary according to reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, the extent of revisions, authors’ response time, and editorial and production requirements. The journal seeks to provide timely evaluation while maintaining scholarly and ethical standards. Acceptance and publication dates are not guaranteed. Authors may request status updates through the submission system.

Where significant delays occur, the editorial office will inform authors of the reason and available options. Authors wishing to withdraw a manuscript must send a written request through the submission system or the editorial office’s published email address, identify the submission, explain the reason, and confirm that all authors agree.

The editorial office will communicate the submission’s status and confirm the outcome in writing. Authors should obtain confirmation of withdrawal before submitting the manuscript elsewhere. If no response is received, authors should follow up through the Journal Contact page and escalate the request to the Editor-in-Chief or publisher, retaining records of their correspondence.

Appeals and Complaints

Authors may submit a reasoned appeal identifying a factual error, procedural concern, or substantive misunderstanding that may have affected an editorial decision. The appeal should identify the submission, explain the grounds, and provide relevant supporting information. Disagreement with a decision alone is not sufficient grounds for reversal.

Appeals and complaints should be sent to the editorial office using the contact details on the Journal Contact page. An editor or other appropriate person who was not responsible for the disputed decision and has no conflict of interest assesses the matter. Additional independent assessment may be obtained where necessary. The editorial office communicates the outcome and its reasons to the author. An appeal does not guarantee reversal of the original decision.

Complaints about an editor’s conduct must be considered by a person who was not involved in the matter and has no conflict of interest. Complaints concerning the Editor-in-Chief may be directed to the publisher, which arranges an impartial assessment without allowing commercial considerations to determine scholarly decisions.

This process should be read together with the journal’s Author Guidelines and Publication Ethics policy. CJLR’s procedures are guided by relevant Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidance for peer reviewers, applied to the nature of legal and socio-legal scholarship.