Author Guidelines

Guidelines for Preparing Manuscripts

Authors submitting to Ceddi Journal of Law and Reality (CJLR) must follow these guidelines and the official CJLR manuscript template. Manuscripts that do not comply with the journal’s scope, ethical requirements, or manuscript preparation guidelines may be returned for correction or rejected before peer review.

A. General Requirements

  1. Manuscripts must be written in clear academic English. Either British or American English may be used, but spelling and terminology must be consistent throughout. Authors are responsible for the accuracy and clarity of legal terminology and translations.
  2. Manuscripts should normally contain 3,000–8,000 words, including the main text and footnotes but excluding the title page, abstract, keywords, tables, figure captions, acknowledgements, declarations, references, and supplementary materials. Submissions outside this range may be considered when the length is justified by the research scope and scholarly contribution.
  3. The title must be concise, informative, and contain no more than 20 words.
  4. Each manuscript must include an English abstract of 150–200 words and 3–5 keywords.
  5. Use APA 7th Edition for citations and references to scholarly literature. Legal authorities must follow Section C. Reference-management software such as Mendeley, Zotero, or EndNote is recommended, but authors must independently verify all citations and references.
  6. Manuscripts must critically examine a legal problem involving the interpretation, application, implementation, enforcement, or consequences of law and make a clear contribution to legal scholarship. Descriptive summaries of legal provisions and studies whose primary contribution lies outside legal scholarship are outside the journal’s scope.
  7. Manuscripts must be original, must not have been previously published as journal articles, and must not be simultaneously under consideration by another journal. Authors must disclose related publications, preprints, theses, conference papers, and substantial overlap with previous work. Reused material must be appropriately attributed, and the manuscript’s distinct contribution must be explained.
  8. Submissions undergo similarity screening using Turnitin or iThenticate. Reports are assessed in context, including properly attributed quotations from legislation, judgments, and other legal authorities. A similarity percentage alone does not establish plagiarism or determine an editorial decision.
  9. All listed authors must have made a substantive scholarly contribution, approved the submitted manuscript, and agreed to be accountable for their contributions and to cooperate in resolving questions about the integrity of the work. Funding, administrative support, seniority, or institutional position alone does not qualify a person for authorship. Other contributors may be acknowledged with their permission.

B. Manuscript Structure

Use the following numbered main sections for all research approaches: 1. Introduction; 2. Methods; 3. Results and Discussion; and 4. Conclusion. Adapt the content and subheadings to the study design while retaining these main headings. Subheadings such as Results, Legal Analysis, Discussion, and Legal Implications may be presented in bold without numbering. The abstract, keywords, acknowledgements, declarations, and references do not require section numbers.

  1. Title: Provide a concise and informative title of no more than 20 words.
  2. Authors and Affiliations: Provide full author names, institutional affiliations, city, country, and the corresponding author’s email on a separate title page. Authors without an institutional affiliation should provide an appropriate designation, such as Independent Researcher, together with their city and country. ORCID identifiers are encouraged but are not mandatory for submission. Include available ORCID identifiers on the title page and in the submission metadata. Exclude author-identifying information from the manuscript prepared for double-blind review.
  3. Abstract: Write a single paragraph of 150–200 words presenting the legal problem and context, objective, research approach or methodology, principal findings or arguments, conclusion, and principal scholarly contribution. Ensure that the contribution is supported by the analysis. Do not include citations, tables, figures, or undefined abbreviations. Use Times New Roman 9 pt and single spacing.
  4. Keywords: Provide 3–5 legal terms or phrases reflecting the main issues, concepts, jurisdictions, or contexts examined. Separate keywords with semicolons and use Times New Roman 8 pt.
  5. Introduction: Explain the legal problem, relevant jurisdiction or jurisdictions, and its significance for rights, justice, legal institutions, governance, or public policy. Critically engage with relevant scholarship and primary legal authorities, identify the research gap, and state the objectives or research questions. Explain the manuscript’s distinct contribution without making unsupported claims that the subject has never been studied.
  6. Methods: Use this heading for all research approaches. Explain the research design, jurisdictional and temporal scope, selection of legal authorities or empirical data, and analytical procedures appropriate to the study.
    • Doctrinal or normative research: Identify the relevant legal sources, criteria for selecting authorities, and methods of interpretation or legal reasoning. Empirical data are not mandatory.
    • Empirical socio-legal research: Describe the setting and dates, sampling or case selection, participants or data sources, collection procedures, analysis, and ethical safeguards. Explain measurement quality, qualitative trustworthiness, or other relevant quality considerations.
    • Comparative legal research: Justify the selection of jurisdictions or legal systems, explain the basis and dimensions of comparison, and consider relevant institutional, historical, or social differences.
    • Source status and analytical limitations: Distinguish the law applicable during the period examined from subsequent amendments or judgments. Explain relevant source limitations and describe any AI or automated tools used as part of the research method, including verification procedures and limitations.
  7. Results and Discussion: Use this main heading for all research approaches. Results and Discussion subheadings may be used without numbering. For doctrinal or normative studies, the Results subheading may be replaced with Legal Analysis or thematic subheadings appropriate to the legal argument. Analysis and discussion may be integrated or presented under separate subheadings within this section.
    • Results or Legal Analysis: Present empirical findings in the order of the research questions, including relevant sample characteristics and uncertainty. For doctrinal or normative research, develop a structured legal argument using primary authorities, relevant scholarship, and consideration of competing interpretations.
    • Discussion: Interpret the findings or legal arguments in relation to the research questions, relevant authorities, and existing scholarship. Explain the scholarly contribution, legal implications, limitations, and alternative interpretations. Distinguish statements of existing law from proposals for reform. Claims about actual implementation, effectiveness, causation, or social outcomes must be supported by appropriate evidence.
    • Legal Implications, where appropriate: Explain the jurisdictions, institutions, or legal contexts to which the findings or arguments apply. Avoid generalising beyond the sources and evidence examined. This material may be integrated into Discussion rather than presented as a separate subsection.
  8. Conclusion: Answer the research questions and summarise the principal findings or arguments, supported scholarly contribution, and implications. Do not introduce new evidence or arguments. Recommendations, if included, must follow from the analysis and distinguish proposals for legal reform from statements of existing law.
  9. Acknowledgements, if applicable: Identify assistance that does not qualify for authorship and obtain permission from named individuals. Provide identifying acknowledgements separately during double-blind review.
  10. Funding Statement: Identify funding sources, grant numbers where applicable, and the funder’s role in the research and publication decision. If no external funding was received, state: “This research received no external funding.” Provide identifying details separately during review.
  11. Author Contributions: Describe each author’s actual contribution. CRediT roles may be used where appropriate. For a single-author manuscript, state that the author was responsible for all aspects of the work. Provide identifying details separately during double-blind review. All authors must approve the final manuscript.
  12. Research Ethics: For research involving human participants or identifiable personal data, report ethical approval, an applicable exemption, or why ethical review was not required under the relevant institutional and jurisdictional requirements. Identify the reviewing body and the approval or exemption reference number, where available. Explain informed consent procedures, any authorised waiver of informed consent, and safeguards for privacy and confidentiality. Public availability of legal records does not remove the need to consider privacy and potential harm. For public-document research, explain accurately when ethical approval and informed consent were not required. Do not claim approval, exemption, or consent that was not obtained or does not apply.
  13. Conflict of Interest: Declare relevant financial, professional, personal, or other competing interests, including involvement in litigation, consultancy, advocacy, or institutional activities related to the subject. If none exist, state: “The authors declare no conflict of interest.”
  14. Data and Materials Availability Statement: Explain whether and how supporting data and materials can be accessed, including legal documents, interview materials, coding frameworks, or other research records where applicable. Provide repository identifiers or official source links and explain legitimate legal, ethical, privacy, or confidentiality restrictions. Do not disclose protected or privileged materials. If no new dataset was generated and the analysis relies on publicly available legal authorities, state this and identify the sources through the citations and references.
  15. Declaration of Generative AI Use: State whether generative AI was used in conducting the research or preparing the manuscript. If used, identify the tool and describe its purpose and extent, including language editing, translation, research, analysis, or drafting. If none was used, state: “The authors did not use generative AI in conducting this research or preparing this manuscript.” Routine non-generative spelling and grammar checks need not be declared. AI tools cannot be authors. Authors remain responsible for all content and must independently verify legal authorities, quotations, citations, factual claims, and analytical conclusions. Confidential, personal, or privileged information must not be uploaded to AI tools without appropriate authorisation and safeguards. Describe research-method uses in Methods.
  16. References: Include all cited scholarly works and legal authorities. Use relevant primary legal sources and authoritative scholarship. Recent literature is encouraged where relevant, while older legislation, judgments, seminal works, and historical sources may be essential. Include DOI links or stable URLs where available. Identify the version, effective date, and legal status of authorities when material to the analysis.

C. Citations and References

Use APA 7th Edition author–date citations for scholarly literature. Authors are encouraged to use reference-management software such as Mendeley, Zotero, or EndNote and must manually verify the accuracy and completeness of all citations and references. Cite legal authorities according to the journal’s requirements, providing sufficient identifying information and pinpoint references to relevant provisions, pages, or paragraphs. Automatically generated citations to legal authorities may require manual adjustment.

Footnotes may be used for supplementary explanations and detailed legal citations; they must not replace author–date citations for scholarly literature. Quotations must be accurate, clearly identified, and accompanied by appropriate pinpoint citations.

  1. Journal articles: Provide author names, year, article title, journal title, volume, issue, page range or article number, and DOI where available.
  2. Books and chapters: Provide author or editor names, year, title, edition where relevant, publisher, and DOI where available. For chapters, include the chapter title, editors, book title, and page range.
  3. Legislation and regulations: Provide the official title, instrument number and year where applicable, jurisdiction, and official publication or stable official URL. Specify the article, section, or subsection in the citation. Indicate amendments or historical versions when relevant.
  4. Court decisions: Provide the case name or decision identifier, court, year or full decision date, official or neutral citation where available, and a stable official URL. Cite the relevant paragraph or page when referring to a specific holding or quotation.
  5. Treaties and international instruments: Provide the official title, adoption or signature date as appropriate, treaty series or official identifier where available, and an official source. Distinguish adoption, entry into force, and applicability to the jurisdiction when relevant.
  6. Non-English legal sources: Retain the official title and provide an English translation in square brackets where needed. Identify author-prepared or unofficial translations when relevant.
  7. Reference-list organisation: List scholarly literature alphabetically using APA 7th Edition and a hanging indent. Legal authorities may be grouped separately under Legislation and Regulations, Cases, and Treaties and International Instruments within References. Apply the arrangement consistently. Every citation must correspond to an identifiable entry, and every listed source must be cited in the manuscript.

Formatting patterns: The following are illustrative templates, not references to actual publications or legal authorities. Adapt legal citations to the identifying conventions of the relevant jurisdiction.

  • Journal article: Author, A. A. (Year). Article title. Journal Title, volume(issue), pages. DOI URL
  • Book: Author, A. A. (Year). Book title (Edition, if applicable). Publisher.
  • Legislation: Official title and instrument number (Year). Jurisdiction. Official source URL. In-text pinpoint: (Short title, Year, art. X).
  • Court decision: Case name, decision or neutral citation (Court, date). Official source URL. In-text pinpoint: (Case name, Year, para. X).
  • Treaty: Official treaty title, adoption or signature date, official identifier. Official source URL. In-text pinpoint: (Short treaty title, Year, art. X).

D. Article Types Accepted

CJLR publishes original research articles within its Focus and Scope. Original research may use doctrinal, normative, statutory, case-law, comparative, empirical socio-legal, or combined approaches. Doctrinal and normative studies do not require empirical data, but must develop an original, critical, and reasoned legal argument and explain its implications for law or legal practice. Literature analysis may support original research, but descriptive literature compilations and standalone review articles are not accepted under the journal’s current article-type policy.

E. Review and Publication Process

Submissions undergo initial editorial screening for scope, originality, scholarly contribution, methodological or analytical rigour, and ethical compliance. Each manuscript proceeding to double-blind peer review is evaluated by at least two independent external reviewers with relevant expertise and no conflicts of interest. Reviewers must not be members of the journal’s editorial team or editorial board. All original research articles published by CJLR undergo this process.

Editorial decisions may include Reject, Major Revision, Minor Revision, or Accept. Authors invited to revise must submit a revised manuscript and a point-by-point response to reviewer and editorial comments. Revised manuscripts may be assessed by the editor or returned for further independent external review, depending on the nature and extent of the revisions. An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.

The Editor-in-Chief makes the final decision based on reviewers’ reports, the handling editor’s assessment, authors’ responses, and compliance with journal policies. If the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, decision-making responsibility is delegated to an appropriate editor without that conflict.

Manuscripts submitted by editorial team or editorial board members are subject to the same standards and review requirements. An editor without a conflict of interest manages the submission and obtains assessments from at least two independent external reviewers. The authoring editor or board member must not select reviewers or participate in editorial deliberations or decisions concerning the manuscript. The editorial office must restrict their access to confidential reviewer identities and internal records for that submission.

Processing times depend on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, the extent of revisions, authors’ response time, and production requirements. Acceptance and publication dates are not guaranteed. Appeals and complaints must be submitted to the editorial office with a clear explanation and supporting information and are handled under the journal’s published procedures.

Accepted articles are freely accessible immediately upon publication without subscription or embargo under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license. Authors retain copyright and grant the journal the right of first publication.

F. Formatting and Submission

  1. Submission format: Submit manuscripts through the CJLR online submission system in editable Word format (.docx). Follow the official CJLR template and replace all instructional text, illustrative examples, and sample content with the manuscript’s actual content.
  2. Page layout: Use A4 paper (21 × 29.7 cm), with margins of 3.76 cm at the top, 2.20 cm on the left, 3.00 cm at the bottom, and 2.11 cm on the right. Retain the template’s page layout.
  3. Typography: Use Times New Roman 10 pt and single spacing for the main text. Use Times New Roman 9 pt for the abstract and 8 pt for keywords, table titles, table contents, and figure captions. Follow the template for title formatting, heading styles, alignment, and spacing. Keep all text legible and editable.
  4. Anonymisation: Upload a separate title page and an anonymised manuscript. Remove author names, affiliations, identifying acknowledgements, tracked changes, identifying comments, and author information in document properties. Cite previous work neutrally rather than removing references needed for the analysis.
  5. Metadata and declarations: Enter complete and accurate author details in the submission system. Provide declarations separately when they reveal identity and restore complete declarations in the accepted manuscript. Consult the editorial office if anonymisation would require withholding ethically or methodologically important information.
  6. Tables: Number tables consecutively using Arabic numerals and cite each table in the text. Place a concise title above the table, left-aligned, in Times New Roman 8 pt. Use editable tables, Times New Roman 8 pt, and single spacing. Place tables near their first citation where practical. Define abbreviations and acknowledge sources where applicable. Explain the principal similarities, differences, or patterns and their significance; do not merely repeat the entries.
  7. Figures: Number figures consecutively in a sequence separate from tables and cite each figure in the text. Place captions below figures, centred, in Times New Roman 8 pt. Ensure that figures are clear and legible, acknowledge sources, and obtain permission for third-party material when required. Explain the elements and relationships shown and their relevance to the legal analysis. Distinguish proposed analytical frameworks from relationships established through empirical evidence.
  8. Equations, where applicable: Use editable equations, number them consecutively, and define all symbols at first use.
  9. Translations: Supply English translations of non-English quotations and explain jurisdiction-specific legal terminology where necessary. Clearly distinguish original wording, translations, and paraphrases.
  10. Supplementary materials: Submit supporting files where needed for transparency and verification, subject to legal and ethical restrictions. Remove identifying information from files supplied to reviewers.
  11. Editorial and production information: The editorial team completes or verifies the DOI, ISSN, volume, issue, publication year, pagination, and Received, Revised, and Accepted dates. Authors must not invent these details. Licensing information and the CC BY logo are managed during production.
  12. Fees: Before submission, consult the journal’s published Article Processing Charges policy for any submission or publication fees and applicable waiver conditions. Editorial evaluation and acceptance decisions remain independent of authors’ ability to pay.

G. Changes to Authorship

Requests to add or remove an author or change the author order after submission must be sent by the corresponding author to the editorial office. The request must explain the reason and include written agreement from all authors, including anyone being added or removed. Changes require editorial approval and may delay processing while the request is assessed. Requests after acceptance receive additional scrutiny. Changes after publication are handled through the journal’s correction procedures when justified.

H. Withdrawal, Journal Policies, and Contact

Authors wishing to withdraw a manuscript must send a written request through the submission system or the editorial office’s published email address, identify the submission, explain the reason, and confirm that all authors agree. The editorial office will communicate the submission’s status and confirm the outcome in writing. Authors should obtain confirmation of withdrawal before submitting the manuscript elsewhere. If no response is received, authors should follow up through the Journal Contact page and escalate the request to the Editor-in-Chief or publisher, retaining records of their correspondence.

Authors must also comply with the journal’s Publication Ethics, Peer Review Process, Plagiarism Policy, AI Policy, Open Access Statement, Copyright and License, and Article Processing Charges policies. Read these guidelines together with those policies.

Submission does not guarantee acceptance or publication. For questions about manuscript preparation, submission, fees, or journal policies, use the editorial office’s contact details on the Journal Contact page.